http://www.rutlandherald.com/article/20120628/NEWS02/706289903
Published June 28, 2012 in the Rutland Herald
Public Service Board needs to be more responsive, advocate says
By SUSAN SMALLHEER
Staff Writer
SPRINGFIELD — Energize Vermont urged area residents concerned about the proposed wood-fired power plant in North Springfield to get behind proposed changes to the makeup of the Public Service Board.
Lukas Snelling, executive director of the Rutland County based nonprofit advocacy group, told about 50 people at the Unitarian Universalist Church on Tuesday evening that the board can ignore a town’s concerns when ruling on a power project.
He said that there is a “gold rush” toward developing renewable energy in Vermont, and he said just because it is called renewable, doesn’t make it right for Vermont.
Energy projects should be “in harmony with the character of our state.”
“Not all renewable energy is good,” he said.
Snelling said the Public Service Board, which is appointed by the governor, needs to be more accountable to the people of the state, and he said Energize Vermont supports a move to make the board elected.
He said his experience is that people assume there will be a townwide vote on any controversial power project, but that people are disappointed when they find out that votes are far from automatic. He said the tradition of town meeting made people expect to be able to have their say, he said.
Snelling, who is the grandson of former Gov. Richard Snelling and Lt. Gov. Barbara Snelling, said the board should have more than just three members, and suggested that membership on the board might be divided geographically, to ensure members are more in touch with local concerns.
Now living in Ira and working against large-scale wind projects, Snelling urged residents to talk to their local legislators — and neighbors – and talk to them again, and again and again.
Many of the people at the meeting are members of NoSAG, the community-based group opposed to the North Springfield Sustainable Energy project, which wants to build a 35 megawatt woodchip-fired power plant in the North Springfield Industrial Park.
The project has filed for a Section 248 permit, or certificate of public good, and NoSAG has been granted intervenor status in the upcoming hearings.
NoSAG member Bob Kischko said that the two sides were exchanging information at this time, as a lead up to the formal hearings.
Kischko said the group had strong support in the North Springfield area of town, and more than 300 people had signed a petition voicing concern about the project, which is a joint proposal of Winstanley Enterprises LLC and Weston Solutions. Winstanley owns the former Fellows Corp., headquarters in the North Springfield Industrial Park, and Weston Solutions has joined with Winstanley to provide practical expertise.
Kischko said “the right scale of renewable energy for Vermont” was affecting communities all over the state.
“Vermont’s a special place,” he said. “Vermont should be able to do better.”
Given the fact that they took jurisdiction away from the Act 250 District Commissions and gave it to the Public Service Board for any projects involving renewable energy, I doubt there are going to be any changes in the near future to the Public Service Board. In fact, in the last legislative session there was an attempt to make the District Commissions behave more like the Public Service Board.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I find the Public Service Board in the main to be distasteful since it has adopted rules which give the illusion of consumer input while in fact making public participation difficult as compared to say the District Commission which has resulted in it becoming basically captured by the utilities it was suppose to regulate, a not uncommon phenomenon and its legal arena the primary playground of the big corporate law firms and large environmental groups -- I can understand that the State was frustrated by the fact that renewable energy projects were being delayed and stymied by NIMBY groups all across the State and as a result the State having placed exclusive jurisdiction of all such projects in the Public Service Board. I agree with Alpin that it is unlikely they will make any change in the near future.
ReplyDeleteyou two are the same bag of hot air
ReplyDeleteLove Springfield, home of the Simpsons, with enough of these tea-partiers and NIMBYs I could rule the world. Love their style, they criticize leaders for not doing things in public, then launch personal attacks when they do. They complain about people leading them astray, but then make snide remarks about people who try to explain why things are as they are. They assert they want a new future, but wallow in the past. With these the election could be a cake walk!
DeleteThey are also the two most lonely people in VT.
ReplyDeleteSounds like they have each other. Lol
Delete